If Everything is Working Class, Then Nothing is Working Class

Are our definitions of class up to date? Does a northern accent really indicate a tough upbringing?

I couldn’t sleep and so I scrolled mindlessly, letting my phone bathe me in the dulcet tones of Mick Lynch, arguably the country’s most visible trade unionist. My ears didn’t particularly prick up until he said that you’re working class, no matter what your job or income bracket, as long as you don’t own the means of production. Do I broadly see the logic of this? Yes. Does it invite the majority of the country to engage in class solidarity? Yes, but doesn’t it rob the term of all of its meaning? It’s entered the famed halls of non-lexicon, a political and cultural fugazi, taking its place in a tomb next to “woke”. I had a sleep paralysis dream the following night; I was trapped in a conversation with a wealthy twenty-something. He doesn’t have a job besides some crypto side hustle, yet he insists that he’s working class. He doesn’t own the means of production, you see.

When did “working class” jump the shark? It’s happened slowly, bit by bit, and has only been detrimental to the genuinely working class. There’s been a creeping flanderisation of what we talk about when we talk about class. We focus on accents and behaviours instead of financial status. We perceive class as a stereotype, a set of characteristics. PSA: class is about income, not accents. As many northerners know, our accents apparently make us working class by association. If you happen to live in the North, stereotypically in Yorkshire or Lancashire, you must be working class. Extra points if you’re further north. It’s as if half the country didn’t know Darlington existed until 2020. Even better, we still think class is about vocation. You can make £200,000 a year, but as long as it’s somewhat adjacent to manual labour, you’re more working class than anyone. You’ve got a badge of honour you can continue to utilise long after you pull up the drawbridge. God forbid you help those living the same struggle you once lived.

To be called working class is some lottery ticket to be chased for personal gain. You  only see the term used as a football to score points: in debate, on the news or at the pub. If you listen to certain unsavoury people you wouldn’t be wrong to assume that working class is now a synonym for white, an easy way to perpetually get the wrong end of the current affairs stick. Again, a further PSA: class is about income, not race. On the other side of this dichotomy are those who seek to claim historical working class heritage as some crude armour of authenticity. This comes in many forms, whether it’s young people staking a claim at parties as a way to stand out or wealthy adults obscuring how out of touch they’ve become. PSA round three: class is about income, not strenuous, far-flung familial relations.

That’s another thing – when did the rich start acting poor? I’m aware a certain false humility has always been a thing in England – the omnipotent desire to seem relatable to those in front of you. But we shouldn’t forget the stark pyramid of class inequality that’s been entrenched in this country far longer. Do we think they all watched some “EAT THE RICH” satire and sussed out how they came across in conversations? This is where you’ll get the hammiest performances of class, clipping their words and attempting a northern lilt in no time. The inverse happens in genuinely working class people. Those who live month to month, feeling the brunt of our economy, don’t seek to make a performance of their reality. They only want financial security and the ability to think further ahead than a few months at a time. 

Our analysis of class has been bastardised by our cultural obsession with the past. It’s far easier for us to cling onto an image and definition solidified in the 1970s, even if that conception of class politics has, for a long time, been on life support. Clearly, we need to talk about what class looks like in 2026. Even if simply to shut up the wealthy kids citing their coal mining great, great grandfather after they’ve passed the five beer threshold.

header: Manchester Libraries (CC BY 4.0)

Category: